Off Campus is expected to devote a season to Jalen Thomas Brooks‘ character Tucker — but who should play his love interest Sabrina?
Based on the Off-Campus book series by Elle Kennedy, the show follows an elite ice hockey team and the women in their lives as they “grapple with love, heartbreak and self-discovery — forging deep friendships and enduring bonds while navigating the complexities that come with transitioning into adulthood,” per the official synopsis.
Season 1 focused on Hannah (Ella Bright) and Garrett (Belmont Cameli), but despite Logan’s (Antonio Cipriano) story being based on the books, Dean (Stephen Kalyn) will be the focus next and then Tucker (Brooks) is expected to follow after Logan’s turn.
“You’re gonna see a lot of Tucker becoming this guy that he’s known to be in the books,” Brooks exclusively told Us Weekly in May 2026 about his character’s journey in season 2.
Which ‘Off Campus’ Stars Are — and Aren’t — Returning for Season 2?
Despite there still being plenty of time for the show to introduce Sabrina, fans have been eagerly awaiting cast news. Luckily, some actresses, including Chandler Kinney and Shabana Azeez, have weighed in on the possibility of them appearing on the highly anticipated role.
Keep scrolling to see the most popular fan casts for Sabrina:
Chandler Kinney
Kinney is booked and busy coming off Pretty Little Liars but she just wrapped the first two seasons of Elle … and told Us she would love to venture over to the Off Campus set for the role of Sabrina.
Antonia Gentry
When Gerry isn’t focused on Ginny & Georgia, something tells Us she would nail it as Sabrina.
Maitreyi Ramkrishnan
Fresh off Never Have I Ever (and a mysterious role in season 2 of Elle), Ramakrishnan is due for another project centered on romance.
Shabana Azeez
If The Pitt fans won’t get to see Javadi and Mateo date on the HBO show, then the least Azeez and Brooks can do is play love interests somewhere else. It doesn’t hurt that Azeez has already given her stamp of approval to play Sabrina — as long as she doesn’t have to play hockey.
Sydney Park
Before becoming a popular fancast choice, Park appeared on The Walking Dead, Pretty Little Liars: The Perfectionists and more.
Which ‘Off Campus’ Stars Originally Auditioned for Different Book Roles?
Savannah Lee Smith
The Gossip Girl and Cruel Intentions alum could be the perfect opposite for Brooks on Off Campus.
Isabella Briggs
Briggs needs to be more booked after The Summer I Turned Pretty and there’s no better time than now with Off Campus.
Sofia Wylie
High School Musical: The Musical: The Series proved that we need more of Wylie on our screens — preferably in a romance project.
Rainbow Wedell
Wedell is best known for her roles in The Wilds, School Spirits and more.
Lexi Underwood
Us has had our eye on Underwood after her time on Little Fires Everywhere and Cruel Summer.
